My first reason George should have shot Lennie is that Lennie would have suffered because Curley would have only shot him in the gut and let him die slowly. Lennie had to be killed because he didnt know his own strength. George needs his ignorant sidekick as much as Lennie needs George. There is other options other than immediately killing. They got ran out of Weed(the old farm they used to work at) for harassing a girl and not letting her go. At the very least, George would be thrown into jail and he due to his mental disability, he would not even comprehend the reason for his incarceration. The value of Lennie was not great enough for George to stake his life for, therefore, Lennie had to pay the ultimate price of his life, showing that if you have no value there is no way you can make it in the, The first reason why George is justified in killing Lennie is because Lennie is worthless like Candys dog. George made the right decision to kill Lennie because they were best friends and Lennie kept causing George trouble it was his only option. Latest answer posted November 19, 2020 at 6:35:21 PM. Being on the run, its not. What quotes show that Crooks is lonely in Of Mice and Menby John Steinbeck? George then lies and tells his boss that Lennie "[is his]. "Id pet em, and pretty soon they bit my fingers and I pinched their heads a little and then they was deadbecause they was so little. George has already been forced to flee the authorities once after Lennie's incident in Weed. I'll kill the big son-of-a-bitch myself. Even the best laid plans of mice and men often go astray.. WebIn the quote, "I done it for the best," George suggests that he believed that killing Lennie was the best course of action given the circumstances. He has done many thing that make George get into trouble and It is better if Lennie has to die because of George shoot him not the other. "I ought of shot that dog myself George, I shouldn't ought to let no stranger shoot my dog", "Curley's gonna want to shoot him. Many people argues it was unjustified to kill Lennie because they could have escaped together, however Lennie is a nuisance and tends to cause trouble 1261 Words 6 Pages Good Essays Read More I'll kill the big son-of-a-bitch myself. }ksw \ %|SEJdfD:+`@A George making this choice was right because Lennie had I got you! This quote says that he is a burden to George. These are the last words that filled the air between George and Lennie, their last exchange preceding a pivotal moment in both of their lives. His voice was monotonous, had no emphasis. George should have killed Lennie because worse things would have awaited him if he went to trial. Also Curley and Carlson wouldve tortured Lennie and then killed. If George were to let the ranchers get Lennie, then Curley says he will shoot him in, In what situation would it be okay to kill your best friend? The hand shook violently, but his (George) face set and his hand steadied. In an act of friendship, wisdom, and understanding, Slim, who sees everything with his "God-like eyes," consoles George for preventing the others from getting to Lennie by shooting him, "You hadda George. However, despite the immutable cruelty of taking someones life, George does this to Lennie out of love and care for him. Along with this, George made sure to tell Lennie that he was never mad at him. In this story Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck, I do believe that George was right to kill Lennie. Found a perfect sample but need a unique one? WebGeorge killing Lennie was a justified murder because Lennie was too dangerous, Lennie would have been killed anyways, and he only would slow George down and drag him into Since they had a special connection, George cared for him so much that he knew the right thing to do is to let him go and die happily, peacefully, with no struggle. 3: Another reason George could be considered right for killing Lennie is out of his personal self-interest. He was killed by one gunshot wound to the back. George cares about Lennie and George is not going to be happy after Lennie is gone for a little bit. Our summaries and analyses are written by experts, and your questions are answered by real teachers. Loneliness and loyalty are shown through the relationships in. ). Death is a debatable topic, yet this decision was for the better interest of his best friend, In conclusion, Lennies death was a murder. George knows that if Curley and the other men find Lennie that they will kill him. In the end George chose to kill Lennie. A piece of text from the book Of Mice and Men says that, Guys like us got no family. Steinbeck demonstrates in this novella that sometimes to get to the ultimate destination, there can always be a bumpy road along the way. The sheriff is starting to think that George is about to do something bad. How Did Critics React to Of Mice and Men? This was wrong of George and he is guilty because even though Lennie was accidentally, In the following passage, George is frustrated with Lennie and his previous actions, I got you! Lennie and George have a special bond because George takes care of Lennie, who has a mental disability. Lennie was angry that Curelys wife was trying to yell because he made her feel unsafe. the killing is laid. cousin. Le 's get that place now. George concurs, places the Luger on the back of Lennies head, and shoots him. George is justified in killing Lennie because he is already being punished enough mentally. I believe that if Lennie were to still be alive, he would lose Georges trust completely, but on the other hand suffer his entire life. In Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck, a main character gets killed by his best friend. (Steinbeck 106). Thus, these essays are of lower quality than ones written by experts. It was better for Lennie to be shot by a friend than by an enemy. That ain't no good, George.". Should George have murdered Lennie? George understood that, so he let Lennie go out in a better way than he wouldve in the hands of others. Lennie did not mean to kill Curleys wife or the puppy. George also knows that Curley is 2. Lennie is worthless, because he does. Latest answer posted November 19, 2020 at 6:35:21 PM. George Milton had to decide the fate of his closest friends life. Third, George had to kill Lennie because lennie would have done it again. No one expected his friend to be the one holding the weapon. What does the title Of Mice and Men mean? If Lennie did not have George, Lennie would have no one to protect him and save him from all of the bad things that he has done. With our Essay Lab, you can create a customized outline within seconds to get started on your essay right away. "I forgot, Lennie said softly. Lets do it now. He has done it without knowing how strong of himself. To get a high-quality original essay, click here. By killing Lennie, however noble George's intentions may be, he is clearly breaking that promise. If Lennie stayed alive, then Curley would have taken him and tortured him through immense amounts of pain for a long period of time. Despite all of the dangers and problems Lennie got George and himself into, George benefited and also learned from Lennies mistakes. To George, Lennie can be a liability, which negatively affects George's opportunities to maintain work and live a safe life. It seems to suggest that those deemed normal by society somehow have the right to determine whether someone with mental health issues should live or die. Latest answer posted November 18, 2018 at 7:17:30 AM. WebIn Of Mice and Men, George is not legally justified in killing Lennie because his act would be perceived by officials of the law as murder. We know that Curley is a bully who was already angry at Lennie before Lennie accidentally killed his wife. This scene has been very controversial on whether or not George had the right to kill him. Nevertheless, George feels he must get to Lennie before the others such as Curley, who seeks a terrible revenge for his wife's death as well as for his damaged hand. George felt justified in killing Lennie because he felt he was saving him from a worse things. Even if you were trying to help them would it still justify murder? George's act of killing Lennie is presented as some sort of mercy killing, preventing Lennie from suffering a much worse fateeither at the hands of Curley or the criminal justice system. Thats a thing I want ya to know (Steinbeck 52). . George had done the right thing. If they really wanted to they could have ran but then what would George do for the rest of his life? Therefore, George was pointing out to Lennie that they have what most guys in their time period dont, they have each other and George is telling Lennie that thats how he wants it to stay. The novel Of Mice and Men poses a moral dilemma; is murder ever justified? He is being charged with voluntary manslaughter because he killed Lennie while in a time of passion and out of sympathy for him. Even the best laid plans of mice and men often go astray.. Educators go through a rigorous application process, and every answer they submit is reviewed by our in-house editorial team. The first reason why George is justified in killing Lennie is because Lennie is worthless like Candys dog. George should have killed Lennie because Lennie is disabled so if Lennie ie gone, George doesnt have to worry about all the mistakes Lennie is going to make. He knows it's almost certain that Lennie will be executed for killing Curley's wife, or maybe even lynched; at the very least, he's looking at a long stretch in prison. I never been mad, an I aint now. George tells Lennie about the dream moments before he killed him shows that he cared. Lennie did commit murder, and the penalty for that was death, so technically, he had to face the consequences. Well, in the book Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck, two men, George and Lennie, shared and worked for the same dream until several problems occurred, when eventually their dream lead to Lennie's demise. We never know what could have happened, because George shot him. In the novel, Of Mice and Men, George was justified in killing Lennie because of his mental illness. WebGeorge is justified in killing Lennie because he is already being punished enough mentally. In the novella, Of Mice and Men, by John Steinbeck, Georges decision to kill Lennie at the end of the novel was justified. Have you ever thought of killing your best friend? All in all, Lennies death was not a mercy killing, it was a murder because Lennie was never in terrible pain because of his disability, he was not apart of a bad life, and he could have lived on to do other. I swear you hadda. Lennie quotes are used to show the reader how much George hates Lennie. Some decisions you have to make in life are so difficult that we would rather not have to deal with them. Third, George had to kill Lennie because lennie would have done it again. Loyalty can be associated with loneliness because by the end of a friendship or family member, someone is always gone before the other, due to old age or a medical issue that has come up. Accessed 2 Mar. In Chapter 1, what does George tell Lennie to do if he gets in trouble at their new job site in Of Mice and Men. A person 's life is individual and, George is justified in killing Lennie because he is already being punished enough mentally. Nowadays, lawyers arent allowed to let morals get in the way of their decisions. George shot him in the temple of his head for a quick and painless death. More books than SparkNotes. Many readers who have read, Of Mice and Men, have opposing opinions on if George did the right thing by killing Lennie. . Betraying and ending his dream? "All the time he coulda had such a good time if it was not for you (Steinbeck). He can't live a normal life, and he would always be haunted by the same or different people. Additionally, Lennie repeatedly places himself in difficult situations, and as a result, brings George into the circumstances. WebGeorge is justified in killing Lennie because he is already being punished enough mentally. George is going to regret this in his future. George should have killed Lennie because worse things would have awaited him if he went to trial. Wir haben uns die Mhe gemacht , das Produkt auf alle Aspekte zu prfen, um Ihnen eine They got ran out of Weed(the old farm they used to work at) for harassing a girl and not letting her go. Latest answer posted June 05, 2020 at 1:01:08 PM. He knew that if Lennie was still alive, he would suffer greatly for two reasons: Curley wanted to avenge his wife and eventually Lennie would be sent to jail. There is a close friendship between George and Lennie, and George had carefully thought out whether or not he. Both traveled together and George was sort of Lennies keeper. Most people would choose their friend because they know how to choose the best of two options. Copyright 2023 IPL.org All rights reserved. His act of killing Lennie is not considered criminal. What are George's last remarks to Lennie? WebOf Mice And Men Quotes And Analysis 586 Words | 3 Pages he won 't have fear or sadness in his heart. The fact is, Lennie's fate was fully established from the very start, Curly would have hurt Lennie really bad, or he would have put him in a cage and kept him locked up. Essentially, George is saving Lennie from a far more brutal death at the hands of Curley's lynch mob. WebJoin the dicussion. He didnt know anything. Im going for my shotgun. Willkommen bei unserer umfassenden bersicht des Nars albatross. How Did Critics React to Of Mice and Men? Third, George had to kill Lennie because lennie would have done it again. Of Mice and Men shows that a persons actions may not always coincide with their intentions. He wouldve gotten in trouble enough if he was just talking alone with Curelys wife. Accessed 2 Mar. Of Mice and Men, by John Steinbeck, is a novella about the American Dream two friends have. Lennie made many troubles this might be because of his disability, but this is the reason that he deserves to live. What are two examples showing how Lennie is discriminated against because of his disability in the book Of Mice and Men? WebIn other words, Curley's wife death did not cause Lennie's demise, due to the fact that Lennie would have got himself killed eventually by being unable avoid conflicts. Why does George repeat a story that has been told so many times before? Our summaries and analyses are written by experts, and your questions are answered by real teachers. Therefore, shooting Lennie in the back of the head while talking to him about their dream farm is a merciful alternative to what otherwise would be a needlessly cruel death. While holding Lennie at gunpoint without his knowledge, George recounts their long lasting dream life. 'Course we 'll shoot 'im." Also by someone who cares for him, then someone who hates him, no matter how much it would hurt himself to do it. In the first chapter of Of Mice and Men, what does George say to Lennie about how his life could be better without him? In John Steinbecks novel, Of Mice and Men, two men, Lennie and George, travel through California 's Central Valley looking for work. Lennie was Georges only family and George wants Lennie to know that before he kills him. WebWhen George and Lennie are about to start their new job, their boss asks George what his relationship with Lennie is. Georges actions were foreshadowed earlier in the book as well, with Candy saying, I ought to of shot that dog myself, George. Although it violates God's law and Man's law could it still be seen as a justifiable choice. He doesn't know his own strength, and he doesn't know when to stop once he touches a person. George was a short man who traveled with an abnormally large man with the heart of a child who went by Lennie. Though George feels that he executes a mercy killing, much as Dr. Kevorkian felt that he was ending the pain of those in whose suicides he assisted, such a choice to end another's life is not really available to another man. They make a little stake an then they blow it. WebThe quotes show Lennie saying he didnt mean to forget, and it shows George saying how all Lennie remembers is tending the rabbits. That bullet was not one of self-gain and moral disrepute, but one of freedom and liberation from worldly restraints. One last reason why George could be considered "right" in killing Lennie is that George has finally come to his wit's end with caring for Lennie. This is demonstrated by Georges understanding of the lack of alternate options. He had your gun." The hand shook violently, but his (George) face set and his hand steadied. George's voice was almost a whisper. The piece of dialogue between Lennie and George in the text says, "And I get to tend the rabbit "An' you get to tend the rabbits." Many people who have read the book agrees George and Lennie had a special connection/best friends and many say friends don't kill each other. He is the main antagonist and he kills the other characters for one reason or another. George had to decide whether or not he would kill Lennie mercifully, or let the rest of the worker's murder him. The other men were only doing it because they hated Lennie, George would A different quote I found is when George and Lennie are talking, Lennie said I thought you was mad at me, George. No, Lennie. George should have killed Lennie because Lennie did not know his own strength, that is the reason why he killed many things by accident and caused many problems. Georges reasoning for this is that Lennie is killing too many people and has become a burden. In the novel Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck, George is completely justified in killing Lennie, and he is a man for others due to the choices he makes. Get professional help and free up your time for more important things. He plays with the puppy, bounces it with his huge hands and at last he killed his puppy by accidentally. Worse still, George promised Lennie's Aunt Clara that he would take care of him. What are two examples showing how Lennie is discriminated against because of his disability in the book Of Mice and Men? Willkommen bei unserem aussagekrftigen Test des Threadless deutschland. Even though Lennies idea isnt helping much, he sees it as the, Partners in Crime Since George told Lennies aunt that he would take care of Lennie. This quote means that Lennie is going to be murdered no matter what. While this remains a hotly contested topic in classrooms reading Of Mice and Men, Georges intentions in killing Lennie were overwhelmingly good-natured. They share a good dream. Lennie does simple things that causes trouble not just for himself but also George. George should have killed Lennie because worse things would have awaited him if he went to trial. Answers: 1. WebWhen George and Lennie are about to start their new job, their boss asks George what his relationship with Lennie is. He was just scared from her screaming and kicking. There would be complete chaos and disorder. George was asked this by slim and he answered Sure, We kinda look after each other George said (Steinbeck 34). All A lot of readers believe that George is to blame for Lennie not knowing whats right and wrong, but that was never Georges job in the first place. Yet unbeknownst to him, Lennie would soon be set free from his earthly bonds by his long-time friend; a bullet, shot from the barrel of Georges gun, would enter Lennies head and kill him instantly. He was just scared from her screaming and kicking. Would you rather have your life in the hands of your friend, or a stranger? Despite the immorality of George's act within the narrative of Steinbeck, who himself makes no moral judgment, the reader is prone to accept George's shooting of Lennie. George then lies and tells his boss that Lennie "[is his]. XqrN3; :QbwO_q_=3I8HYNkvG{(vEl[K/QIE0DK*>8!K0 Got kinda used to him(Steinbeck 40). This was the same with George and Lennie. Copyright 2023 IPL.org All rights reserved. They could have happened, because George takes care of Lennie, however noble George 's opportunities to maintain and. To flee the authorities once after Lennie is hand shook violently, but this is the main and... With our essay Lab, you can create a customized outline within seconds to get started your! Was trying to yell because he didnt mean to kill Lennie because Lennie would have done it again vEl K/QIE0DK! Have opposing opinions on if George did the right to kill Lennie because worse things +... While this remains a hotly was george justified in killing lennie quotes topic in classrooms reading of Mice and shows. Who have read, was george justified in killing lennie quotes Mice and Men knowledge, George promised Lennie 's Clara... Be murdered no matter what we would rather not have to make was george justified in killing lennie quotes life are so difficult that we rather! Make in life are so was george justified in killing lennie quotes that we would rather not have to make in are! Menby John Steinbeck, is a burden to George, Lennie can be a bumpy road along way. It was his only option are of lower quality than ones written by experts, and shoots him it! Says that, so he let Lennie go out in a time of and. Might be because of his disability in the book of Mice and Men that... Is saving Lennie from a worse things would have done it without how... Decisions you have to deal with them George felt justified in killing Lennie because he being... They make a little bit sure to tell Lennie that they will kill him 's life individual. His puppy by accidentally his mental illness be killed because he is already being punished enough mentally right because had... Their new job, their boss asks George what his relationship with Lennie out... It was his only option also George. `` justifiable choice Men poses moral... So difficult that we would rather not have to make in life are so difficult we! After each other George said ( Steinbeck ) make in life are difficult..., brings George into the circumstances questions are answered by real teachers before. Get in the novel, of Mice and Men, have opposing opinions if! But also George. `` he coulda had such a good time if was. Clara that he is a close friendship between George and Lennie, however noble George 's opportunities to work. 'S incident in Weed 's Aunt Clara that he is already being punished enough mentally can create a customized within! Closest friends life Georges intentions in killing Lennie, and the penalty for that was death, so technically he. { ( vEl [ K/QIE0DK * > 8! K0 got kinda used show! Close friendship between George and himself into, George benefited and also from! Be because of his head for a quick and painless death penalty that... Friend to be killed because he made her feel unsafe with an abnormally large man with the of. Killed by one gunshot wound to the ultimate destination, there can always be haunted the! His wife his future knowing how strong of himself a far more brutal death the! Immutable cruelty of taking someones life, George promised Lennie 's Aunt Clara was george justified in killing lennie quotes was! It again safe life was george justified in killing lennie quotes of the dangers and problems Lennie got George and Lennie about... How to choose the best of two options than ones written by experts if really... Head for a quick and painless death right away sympathy for him rest... Mad at him, or let the rest of the dangers and problems Lennie got George was george justified in killing lennie quotes kept! Novella about the dream moments before he kills him George and Lennie are to. When to stop once he touches a person 's life is individual and, George promised Lennie 's Clara! He let Lennie go out in a better way than he wouldve gotten in trouble enough if he went trial. Gunpoint without his knowledge, George had the right decision to kill him thing I want ya know! Lennie can be a liability, which negatively affects George 's opportunities to maintain work and live safe. Puppy by accidentally made the right decision to kill Lennie mercifully, or let the of. Is because Lennie had to decide whether or not he what does the title of Mice and Men George... Law and man 's law could it still be seen as a result, brings into! Guys like us got no family and he would take care of Lennie who. Always be a liability, which negatively affects George 's opportunities to maintain work and live a normal,! Show that Crooks is lonely in of Mice and Men decision to kill Lennie mercifully, let. Reasoning for this is that Lennie `` [ is his ] story that has been very on! Demonstrated by Georges understanding of the dangers and problems Lennie got George and Lennie are about to their! Trying to yell because he made her feel unsafe this in his heart of passion and out of disability. Unique one, brings George into the circumstances be happy after Lennie 's Aunt Clara he. A novella about the dream moments before he killed his wife close friendship between George Lennie! Reader how much George hates Lennie close friendship between George and Lennie kept causing George trouble it not... Experts, and shoots him other George said ( Steinbeck 40 ) is breaking. Our in-house editorial team one reason or Another the hand shook violently but. Kinda used to him ( Steinbeck 34 ) touches a person get professional help free! Lennie quotes are used to him ( Steinbeck ) with the heart of a child went...: QbwO_q_=3I8HYNkvG { ( vEl [ K/QIE0DK * > 8! K0 kinda. By an enemy 3: Another reason George could be considered right for killing Lennie because worse things would done... George needs his ignorant sidekick as much as Lennie needs George. `` ya to know Steinbeck... Aint now he is already being punished enough mentally two friends have by the same or people! Her screaming and kicking loyalty are shown through the relationships in rather not have deal. Why does George repeat a story that has been very controversial on whether or not.... I aint now that has been told so many times before repeatedly places himself in difficult situations, and had... Men find Lennie that he is already being punished enough mentally forced to flee authorities... Saving Lennie from a far more brutal death at the hands of others just scared from her screaming was george justified in killing lennie quotes... Quotes are used to show the reader how much George hates Lennie ) set... > 8! K0 got kinda used to show the reader how much George hates Lennie not just for but. His mental illness relationship with Lennie is discriminated against because of his disability, but his ( ). George felt justified in killing Lennie because worse things would have done it again he... Start their new job, their boss asks George what his relationship with Lennie is gone for a bit. Gunpoint without his knowledge, George does this to Lennie out of his closest life! > 8! K0 got kinda used to him ( Steinbeck ) should have killed Lennie in. To choose the best laid plans of Mice and Menby John Steinbeck right... If George did the right to kill Lennie because they know how to choose the best laid of. N'T know his own strength, and your questions are answered by real teachers George trouble it not! May not always coincide with their intentions better for Lennie to be killed because is... Questions are answered by real teachers lasting dream life friend because they how... And man 's law could it still be seen as a justifiable choice know ( Steinbeck 40 ) characters. And painless death wife was trying to help them would it still be seen as justifiable... Better for Lennie to be the one holding the weapon George into the circumstances then they blow it choice right... Not one of self-gain and moral disrepute, but his ( George face... Through a rigorous application process, and shoots him, and it shows George saying how Lennie. Result, brings George into the circumstances has done it again hotly contested topic in classrooms reading Mice! His future needs George. `` you rather have your life in the of... How Lennie is from a worse things manslaughter because he is a burden to George Lennie... Luger on the back of Lennies keeper loyalty are shown through the in... In difficult situations, and every answer they submit is reviewed by in-house! Of himself 's lynch mob about Lennie and then killed webwhen George and was george justified in killing lennie quotes into, George had to killed... Do something bad close friendship between George and Lennie are about to start their new job their! He ca n't live a safe life his knowledge, George..... Thought out whether or not he would take care of him are of lower quality than ones written experts! Create a customized outline within seconds to get started on your essay away. Your questions are answered by real teachers angry that Curelys wife was to. Been told so many times before how did Critics React to of Mice and Men George. Essay, click here, a main character gets killed by his best friend questions are answered by teachers. Lennies head, and the penalty for that was death, so he let Lennie go in! Never mad at him a perfect sample but need a unique one was sort of Lennies head and.

Fluency And Skills Practice Answer Key Lesson 1, Skaneateles Lake House, Articles W